Saturday, 14 December 2013

"The Machinist" (2004) true meaning explained.

"The Machinist" was a 2004 movie revolving around Trevor Reznik (played by Christian Bale) - an industrial worker, who hasn't slept in a year and, after a weird chain of events starts occuring, is starting to doubt his own sanity.

SPOILERS AHEAD. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED.

So, if you're reading this, chances are, you have seen the movie.

The movie is a bit of a puzzler, but in the end everything is pretty neatly explained. Reznik regains his memories, discovers, that he has killed Nicholas, turns himself in and is finally able to sleep. Seems, that it's all there is to it. But...

After watching the movie I went on IMDb to give this movie a rating, check out trivia etc. And then I saw this post on movie's message board, that user black_mass had made.

Reznik is already DEAD, right? And the film is his purgatory?


"Psh... People and their conspiracies." I thought. But out of curiosity I opened the post and suddenly... Everything started to make a perfect sense.

Reznik was dead, when the movie began, and he was dead, when the movie ended. If you read the post, you'll already understand it.

So in the end of the movie, he remembers, that after he hit Nicholas with his 1969 Pontiac Viper, he fled the scene. He drove away with a shattered windshield and, completely shocked, entered a tunnel. As you'll remember it was the same tunnel, in which he entered, when he chased the same Pontiac Viper (driven by Ivan with someone (who was apparently Nicholas) in passenger's seat) earlier in the film. After he exits the tunnel, he tries to read Pontiac's number plate and nearly crashes in another car. And that's how he died. Another proof for this is one earlier scene in the movie. When Reznik reports a hit&run, blaming Ivan and his Pontiac, the officer comes up to him saying, that this car is registered to his name. But afterwards he says something else.

"Nearly a year ago you reported it as being totally wrecked."

So that's the apparent scenario, we are subtly pointed towards. Reznik hits Nicholas, flees in complete shock, enters the tunnels, crashes into another car and dies.

Now, that we have this theory, let's look for some evidence.

Firstly, the fact, that he's hanging out with Nicholas, who's already dead.

Secondly, when Nicholas goes to Route 666 attraction with Reznik, it kind of shows Reznik's life story:
1. There's a waitress cleaning dishes = Reznik going to the same cafeteria all the time.
2. Indian holding a detached hand = Reznik causes Miller to lose his hand.
3. A woman in black crying over someone's grave = Maries losing her son.
4. A hanging man with a sign nearby, that says "Guilty" = Reznik is guilty of killing Nicholas.
5. "Shady Lady Motel" = Reznik's relationship with hooker Stevie.
6. A policist holding a sign, that says "Stop, School zone!" and a child, that appears on tracks afterwards = Yet again, Reznik killing Nicholas.
7. A crashed car with a body nearby = Reznik crashing into a car and dying.
8. Road splits. One leads to "Highway to hell" other - "Road to salvation". Nicholas tries to steer to salvation, but car moves to "Highway to hell" = Reznik goes to hell.
9. Car drives into a tunnel, Reznik has flashbacks to the accident (that he's unaware at the moment) = Reznik is in hell. Which the movie takes place in.

Thirdly, Reznik had a ring in his Pontiac, that said "Route 66".

Fourthly, Reznik's suffering in hell - insomnia, stomach issues, Igor etc.

And fifthly, movie's ending. At the end Reznik finally understood, what he has done. He goes and turns himself in to police. They lock him in a completely white prison celll, where he finally is able to sleep.

I interpret it as Reznik repenting his sins and finally turning in to "Road to salvation".

All this seems just a bit too much to be a coincidence, eh? Well, decide for yourself.

All credit goes to IMDb user black_mass for coming up with this amazing idea.




18 comments:

  1. hey it was an awesome explaination..
    Thnx for helping me

    ReplyDelete
  2. thank you so much

    ReplyDelete
  3. This theory is solid, Stevie and Maria both comments "If you lose anymore weight, you won't exist." As he continues to lose weight through out the film. Also in bar he washes his hands with pure lye, which I believe would burn the heck out of him...

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is an exellent explanation but can anyone explain the character of Ivan please?? who or what is he symbolizing??

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Just a sleazy, nasty characterization of his guilt. Ivan leads him through the path of accepting what he did.

      Delete
    2. Maybe it's the devil who plays around him.the scene in which the devil head appears on top of the the entrance to Horror show showcases the His alter Ego.the devil himself

      Delete
    3. I believe Ivan is his conscience.

      Delete
  5. The explanation that reznik dies in the movie is completely incorrect.

    ReplyDelete
  6. How could he report the car as "totally wrecked" if he died in the accident?

    ReplyDelete
  7. How could he report the car as "totally wrecked" if he died in the accident?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good question. However, if Reznik had imagined the whole thing, meaning all of the events in the movie including when the officer told him that he had reported his car "totally wrecked", then the accuracy of any claim made by any character is basically irrelevant, because it doesn't need to be accurate in order for the theory to hold.

      Delete
  8. It explains some things like the "totally wrecked" car, the purely white jail cell, etc... But it also begs some questions, like one asked above: "How could he report the car as 'totally wrecked' if he died in the accident?". Also, does this mean that all of the events in the movie were imagined by Reznik? There is a lot that makes me think that Reznik has created this delusion on top of reality, stuff that shows a separation between the two worlds. Of course, Reznik could have very well imagined a more plausible set of events to go along with the wacky, outlandish events that he clearly imagined. But that theory would seem to lead to more questions than answers, and the questions that it does answer aren't answered definitively, and other explanations (the white cell could pure cinematic symbolism, representing his clear conscience, rather than a symbol of purgatory or something).

    ReplyDelete
  9. agree with you , he didnt die , his guilt is eating him alive and finally he goes clean and admit it to police. i believe that way.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The tunnel represents his choice to admit his guilt. He is always taking the left turn (the wrong way) in the end he takes the right turn.

    ReplyDelete
  11. The tunnel represents his choice to admit his guilt. He is always taking the left turn (the wrong way) in the end he takes the right turn.

    ReplyDelete
  12. its a Christian Bale Thriller. where anything can and does happen. Just listen in the beginning. Anyone who has not really slept in a year, is going to have a brain that is about dead or is dead, and sees things the way he wants them to be, not as they are. A brain deprived of sleep is not a real person.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Best online casino for you - Kadangpintar
    We've developed a number of online casinos and are pleased 바카라 사이트 to announce that all players can now play 메리트 카지노 쿠폰 the games from their respective kadangpintar

    ReplyDelete
  14. casino.myladyjackson.com - DrmCD
    Casino.myladyjackson.com 강릉 출장마사지 - 이천 출장샵 All rights reserved. 안산 출장샵 Casino. Myladyjackson.com. Terms and 문경 출장샵 Conditions 수원 출장샵 apply.

    ReplyDelete